Tax Extender Bill Fails Yet Again

The Senate on Thursday failed to advance the American Jobs and Closing Tax Loopholes Act (H.R. 4213) (pdf), the “tax extender” bill that would have provided for additional months of emergency unemployment benefits and continued various tax relief programs, among other things. The 57-41 vote fell three votes short of limiting debate and scheduling final floor action on the measure. The latest version of the bill offered by Sen. Max Baucus (D-MT) was introduced on Wednesday in an effort to trim costs and gain enough support to pass it. Previous Senate-passed tax extender legislation would have extended the COBRA premium subsidy and various unemployment programs through the end of the year. In May, the House approved this legislation once COBRA premium subsidy extensions were dropped. Earlier this month, the Senate introduced a substitute version of the bill that lacked certain defined contribution pension plan fee disclosure provisions. After it became evident that he did not have enough votes to limit debate on the bill, Baucus introduced a scaled back version that ultimately – like the latest edited version – failed to gain sufficient approval. At this point, Senate passage of the bill in any form appears unlikely.

Photo credit:  MBPHOTO, INC.

Senate Approves Pension Funding and "Doc Fix" Bill; Larger Tax Extender Bill Stalls

On Friday, the Senate unanimously approved the Preservation of Access to Care for Medicare Beneficiaries and Pension Relief Act, (pdf) a bill that reverses a 21 percent payment cut for doctors in Medicare and TRICARE, updates the physician payment formula through November 30, 2010, and provides temporary funding relief for single- and multi-employer pension plans that suffered significant losses in 2008. With respect to the pension relief provisions, according to a summary, (pdf) employers that elect the relief would be required to make additional contributions to the plan if they pay compensation to any employee in excess of $1 million, pay extraordinary dividends, or engage in extraordinary stock buybacks during the first part of the relief period. Additional relief would be available to certain plans sponsored by charitable organizations. The legislation now needs approval by the House.

This last-minute compromise comes after the Senate on Thursday failed to move forward a more expansive “tax extender” bill, the American Jobs and Closing Tax Loopholes Act (H.R. 4213). (pdf)  On Wednesday, Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus (D-MT) unveiled an amended version of the bill in order to reduce its price tag from $140 billion to $110 billion. Generally, this measure would have continued a number of individual and business tax cut programs and extended emergency unemployment, in addition to providing a number of pension funding relief measures.

This bill had been gradually scaled back over the last few weeks in the hope of gaining sufficient support. In May, the House approved this legislation once COBRA premium subsidy extensions were dropped. Last week, the Senate introduced a substitute version of the bill that lacked certain defined contribution pension plan fee disclosure provisions. After it became evident Wednesday that the Senate did not have enough votes to limit debate on the bill, Baucus introduced the trimmed down draft. Despite Baucus’s efforts to reduce the bill’s costs, however, the Senate voted 56-40 – four votes shy of the necessary 60 – to limit debate on the measure and submit it to the Senate floor for a final vote.

During yesterday’s Senate session, Sen. Robert Casey (D-PA) offered an amendment (S. Amt. 4371) to the bill that would extend the COBRA premium subsidy program through November 2010. In urging approval of his amendment, Casey stated that “[w]ithout the extension of the COBRA Premium Assistance Program, a report from the National Employment Law Projects predicts as many as 150,000 Americans each month will lose out on the subsidies necessary to afford quality health care.” At this point, however, the fate of the tax extender bill – and its amendments – is unclear.

Senate Version of Extender Bill Eliminates Pension Fee Disclosure Provision

On Tuesday, the Senate resumed consideration of the American Jobs and Closing Tax Loopholes Act (H.R. 4213) (pdf), also known as the “tax extender” or “jobs bill” that would extend emergency unemployment compensation and other tax break programs, as well as provide temporary pension funding relief. Although the Senate passed a tax extender bill in March, the House of Representatives on May 28 narrowly cleared a scaled-back version of this legislation that omitted a number of the original provisions, including an extension of the premium COBRA subsidy. The revised Senate bill unveiled this week, which has been offered in the form of a substitute amendment, does not contain the defined contribution plan fee disclosure provisions that would have required the creation of rules relating to fees incurred in connection with defined contribution plans (such as 401(k) plans) for plan administrators and plan participants. A COBRA subsidy extension was not among the changes included in the Senate substitute either. A summary of all of the changes made by the Senate amendment can be found here. (pdf)

Other provisions contained in the House-passed version, such as those providing for refundable alternative minimum tax (AMT) credits for corporations making domestic investments; an employer wage credit for activated military reservists; temporary pension funding relief for single- and multi-employer plans; and unemployment compensation program extensions, remain intact. With respect to the unemployment provisions, the substitute amendment summary (pdf) explains that the bill would do the following:

  • Extend the Emergency Unemployment Compensation (EUC) program through November 2010. This program – which provides up to 53 weeks of extended unemployment benefits depending on a state’s unemployment rate – ended in May.
  • Continue the Extended Benefits (EB) program through November 2010. The EB provided up to an additional 13 to 20 weeks of benefits in certain states (13 weeks for states at or above 6.5% unemployment and another 7 weeks for states at or above 8% unemployment).
  • Extend Federal Additional Compensation (FAC) through November 2010. FAC, which was also phased out in May, increases unemployment benefits by $25 a week. 
  • Eliminate the penalty for part-time employment in the EUC program. As stated in the summary, the bill coordinates EUC benefits with regular unemployment benefits by providing states with a number of options to allow EUC claimants to remain eligible for the EUC program when they become newly entitled to state unemployment compensation if switching to state benefits would reduce their weekly UI check by at least $100 or 25%.

The effort to reinstate the COBRA subsidy extension may continue as more amendments are offered and the bill continues to take shape over the coming days. 

Photo credit: borisyankov

House-Approved Extender Bill Omits COBRA Extension

On Friday the House of Representatives narrowly approved (215-204) a scaled-back version of the American Jobs and Closing Tax Loopholes Act (H.R. 4213), a bill that would extend a number of benefit programs, including emergency unemployment payments, and provide for pension funding relief and fee disclosures. Details of this joint legislation were first unveiled last week.  Due to the measure’s escalating cost estimate, however, members of Congress agreed to trim a number of benefit extensions to ensure enough votes for passage, including a last-minute decision to omit the COBRA premium subsidy extension entirely. Other provisions, such as the one providing for an extension of the emergency unemployment benefits program, was reduced by one month. Specifically, as outlined in a summary (pdf) of the revised bill, certain provisions would do the following:

Unemployment Insurance

  • Extension of Emergency Unemployment Compensation (EUC) program. The Emergency Unemployment Compensation (EUC) program – set to expire at the end of May 2010 – would be extended through November 2010.
  • Extension of Extended Benefits (EB) program. 100% federal funding for the Extended Benefits (EB) program is scheduled to phase-out at the end of May 2010. This program provides up to an additional 13 to 20 weeks of benefits, depending on the rate and extent of unemployment per state. The bill would extend full funding for the EB program through November 2010.

Pension Funding Relief

  • Single employer plan funding relief measures include: extended period for single employer defined benefit plans to amortize certain shortfall amortization bases; application of an extended amortization period to plans subject to prior law funding rules; suspension of certain funding level limitations; temporary allowance of election to apply balances against minimum required contribution; modification of the reporting requirement by requiring additional reporting if aggregate unfunded vested benefits of plans maintained by the sponsor exceed $75 million; and rollover of amounts received in airline carrier bankruptcy.
  • Multiemployer plan funding relief measures include: optional use of 30-year amortization periods; optional longer recovery periods for multiemployer plans in endangered or critical status; modification of certain amortization extensions under prior law; alternative default schedule for plans in endangered or critical status; and the provision of transition rules for the certifications of plan status.

Fee Disclosures

  • Defined Contribution Plan Fee Disclosure. The bill would amend the Internal Revenue Code and the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) to provide disclosure rules relating to fees incurred in connection with defined contribution plans (such as 401(k) plans) to plan administrators and plan participants. Among other things, these fee disclosure provisions require 401(k) service providers to disclose to employers all fees assessed against the participant’s account, broken down into three categories: plan administration and recordkeeping fees, investment management fees, and all other fees. Additionally, the bill mandates that before plan enrollment, workers receive basic investment disclosures, such as information on risk, return, and investment objectives. Moreover, a worker’s quarterly statement would be required to list total contributions, earnings, closing account balance, net return, and all fees subtracted from the account.

Miscellaneous Provisions

  • Refundable AMT credits for corporations making domestic investments. The bill would allow corporations to receive a refund of a portion of their alternative minimum tax (AMT) credits if in 2010 they invest in capital equipment for use in the United States.
  • Employer wage credit for activated military reservists. The bill would extend for one year (through 2010) the provision that provides eligible small business employers with a credit against the taxpayer’s income tax liability for a taxable year in an amount equal to twenty percent (20%) of the sum of differential wage payments to activated military reservists.

More information on this bill and the changes made to it can be found on the House Ways and Means Committee webpage.

Because the Senate already recessed for the Memorial Day break, it will not begin consideration of this measure until June 7 at the earliest. In the meantime, the premium COBRA subsidy and emergency unemployment insurance programs are set to expire before Congress reconvenes.

Photo credit:  MBPHOTO, INC.